Finding My Brother…Birth Family and Adoption…and My Experience Being on Both Sides of It

There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story inside you. ~ Maya Angelou



Birth family. It’s an interesting subject. For some, it’s a touchy subject that adoptive parents and even some adopted kids are scared to get too close to. Do you really open that door when you don’t know what is on the other side? Will you be faced with rejection or some horrible story you never knew about your past, or will the birth family start expecting to be supported or try to join in your life as if they have always been a part of it? There are all kinds of fears that stem from this subject. Some people even choose to act like that door to their past doesn’t exist. If they never mention birth family or talk about their child’s story, or their own story if they are adopted, then somehow they think that entire part of their history can just evaporate.

This subject of birth family is doubly meaningful for me because I can look at it from both sides of an adoption story.  #1. I am an adoptive mom to four amazing kids we adopted from Ethiopia. I have my story to tell about searching for and finding my children’s birth families and keeping them connected to them. But there is a second perspective I can view birth family from. It is what helps me better than anything else be able to relate to my adopted children’s birth families. My entire introduction into the adoption world came as a surprise to me. In the year 2000 I discovered I am the biological sister to a long lost brother who had been adopted to another family that I never knew about.  My brother was the adopted child and I was the birth family that was looking for him. I was 26 when I found him and he was 31 and didn’t even know I existed.

My brother was my first introduction to adoption. Before he came into my life I had honestly never even thought about adoption or anything associated with it. I thought it was only something people did when they couldn’t birth children naturally. At the time I was pregnant with my fifth child, so obviously I had never thought about adoption before.

Boy did I have a lot to learn! 

It was the year 2000 when I finally met my brother.

Years before this, I heard a story from my Grandmother right before she died. She said a woman showed up on her doorstep in 1968 while my father was away in the Vietnam war and claimed her daughter was pregnant. She also claimed that it was my father that got her daughter in that predicament. My grandmother told me that she didn’t believe the woman and basically shut the door in her face and told her to get a blood test if she wanted to prove something. The woman left and they never heard anything from her again after that. There was no follow up.

That is, not until 30 years later.

This story popped up again between me and my sister and I decided to do some research to find out if, in fact, I could possibly have another sibling out there in this world somewhere. My father, who was also interested to see what I found out, gave me the girl’s maiden name and the city she lived in back in the 60’s. I called enough phone numbers in that city until I finally found her parents, who were elderly, and left a message for her to call me back.  I said there was an old friend trying to reach her.

The next night…SHE CALLED…excited to find out which old friend was trying to reach her.  (insert bug-eyed emoji) I had to drop a bombshell of hard questions on this woman and open a major skeleton in her closet.

I said, “Yes, you knew my father back in 1968.”

She asked me excitedly, “What is his name?”

I told her his name.


Me, “Hello?” (insert super bug-eyed emoji again)

“Yes, I’m still here.” with a major somber tone change in her voice.

Hesitantly, but willingly, she went ahead and answered my questions about what happened back in 1968 while my father was in Vietnam. She told me she did become pregnant before he left for war and that it was definitely his child. She said she was banned from her home and told not to return until she “took care of it”. So thankfully, instead of abortion, she chose to go to another town and live with her older brother until she had the baby. She told me she had a baby boy and placed him immediately up for adoption and then returned to her home. She said she thought that perhaps the family that adopted him lived in New York somewhere. She told me the Dr’s name and the baby’s birthdate that was ingrained in her mind…and that was it. She also told me to NOT  give him her information if I found him because her husband and two children STILL knew nothing about the baby or that time in her life. (Ugh!) All these years later it was still a secret buried deep in her soul and covered with shame that her family had put on her so long ago during that time period. I couldn’t imagine what she had lived with all these years keeping a secret like that for so long. 

And then what it must have been like for her to get such a random phone call out of the blue that brought it all back to the surface 30 years later. I’ve learned that in life your past and especially your secrets usually catch up to you one way or another so it is always so much better to face it first before it meets up with you unexpectedly. But sooner or later, the two WILL meet up, either in person or in the psychologist’s office.

I couldn’t believe she confirmed I had an older brother out in the world somewhere. I was the oldest of 4 girls and a younger brother at the time. Was I really not the oldest? So strange to think about.

Me as the oldest, with all my siblings and my Dad.


I took that information she gave me and searched through adoption search engines for months. I found nothing. I gave up. I then returned to the computer randomly one day, months later, and sat down and typed his birthdate and info into a new registry site I had just found. I had only been on the computer for about 5 minutes. And guess what?



The girl at the registry site said it was a 99% match and that he would be in touch. She said that he had to be looking as well for him to have put his info into that registry in the first place. She told me his name was Michael. Wow! I had a brother named Michael.

We waited. And waited, with anticipation. Two weeks passed before he finally reached out to me. It turns out that he actually never even looked for his birth family. It was his new wife who had entered his info into the system and she never told him. He just got a phone call one day congratulating him that they had located his father’s side of his birth family. He had no idea what they were talking about until his wife explained. He said it took him two weeks to wrap his head around it and work up his nerve to open that door to his unknown birth family, not knowing what he would find on the other side.

When we spoke on the phone for the first time it was literally like city mouse and country mouse. He had grown up in the Bronx of New York and had the thickest New York accent I had ever heard. I had grown up in the cornfields of Ky and sounded as backwoods as he had ever heard, I’m sure. Not to mention I was 26 and due to give birth to my 5th child any day. I can’t imagine what image he had in his head of his new, countryfide, barefoot and pregnant sister from Ky saying “Hey, welcome to the family, big bro!”, in true Ky fashion. Lol!

But it turned out, HE WAS AMAZING!

We received our first picture of him through our new computer at the time. He was recently married so he sent us his wedding picture. We all just couldn’t believe it! He was a clone of my father! Like, we were freaking out! How could he have been out there all those years, look identical to my father, and we never knew about him?

This was the very first picture we ever saw of Michael.
This is a picture of my Dad when he was young. You can see his resemblance to Michael.

We learned Michael was a New York City firefighter at that time. He was newly married and his wife was a NY City, policewoman. A few months later he flew to Ky for the first time, met his long, lost, birth family, and we all immediately loved him! He was the older brother I never had. He was such a kind soul. We all had an instant connection with him. Ironically, we popped up in his life and found him just after his adoptive father had passed away. He was an only child so it was just he and his Mom left in his immediate family.

Now he had all this new, found family to call his own!


This was the year 2000. None of us had any idea what was about to hit New York City within the next year in 2001. 

911…World Trade Center…and my new brother was a NY City Firefighter.

All firefighters immediately got called to the World Trade Center site that day. His unit was one of the first to go up into the World Trade Center. 



As soon as I saw the news I tried to call him as well as my sister, who also lived in New York, not far from the Trade Center.

There have been so many lessons that I have learned since this time. So many ways I have seen God’s hand in this story and how He orchestrated the timing of everything. So many ways my eyes have been opened to adoption, birth family, and all the emotions that come with it.

We had just found my brother a year earlier. Is it really possible that we could have lost him? So many questions and panic were swirling through my mind as I tried to get in touch with him.

Stay tuned for Part 2. 


7 thoughts on “Finding My Brother…Birth Family and Adoption…and My Experience Being on Both Sides of It

  1. Wow Kelly!!!! What an incredible story of life!!!! So glad you found Michael and he has you all in his life. Amazing and sooooo precious gift from God.
    Thank you for sharing.
    Us too would like to find George’s birth father (time is ticking). We have searched and searched. Made one phone call to a man who we believe would be him, but he said no to George’s questions and wished him luck. (He thinks that was him, so he stopped looking). George’s mom just passed away last year, so I want the search to start again, but not sure where to start. I’m sure his birth father is in his late 70’s by now. His name is John Micca, originally from NY but met his Mom in Cedar Rapids Iowa in the 60’s, had a fling and she got pregnant with George (thanks be to God!!). We think he lives in Surprise, Az which is where we called, and where the man said it wasn’t him. 😢.
    Interesting thought from Blake though… (he is so smart), he said, “so what is my true last name?” “Should it be Micca? Or Carter?” “Carter is not blood related, so really I don’t have a last name.” Stopped us in our tracks. Makes you really think. What a deep question and he was 15 at the time. Hmmmm…
    Anyway, thanks for sharing (and listening). I look forward to reading Part 2. And praying it is a happy Part 2.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wow, Catherine! I love your story too. I say start looking again. You never know. This post could be the nudge you need. But you are right. Time is sticking. I’ll pray you guys find him for George to have some closure. ❤️ And Blake is wise.


  2. My mom was adopted and we have wondered many times about her birth family. She was born in Springfield IL August 24, 1949. She is going to be 70 years old this year. I would love to be able to help her locate her birth parents but I figure they are probably deceased by now. All we know was she was extremely malnourished at birth and she only weighed about 2 pounds at birth. She was in the hospital for 2-3 months before she was adopted. Her adoptive mother told her that she believed she saw her birth mother looking at her while she was still in the hospital nursery as she said the women was looking at her with tears in her eyes. She said it appeared as if she did not have a choice but to give up my mom. We were told that records were sealed back then and so we probably would not be able to locate her birth parents. We were also informed that Catholic Charities burned and records were lost. We would love to know if you can share with us the search engines to use or let us know how we can find out who her birth parents are. Thanks for your story. I look forward to reading part 2. God bless you!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Julie. I definitely say it’s worth the search. It will take a little effort but even if her birth parents are deceased you could perhaps find their children and get some answers for your mom. But perhaps birth mom was young like me when I had my first child and is still alive. I was 18 when my daughter was born. I would start by contacting Catholic Charities in Springfield. tel:217-523-9201. Then you will need to start reaching out to as any adoption registry sites as you can. Here is a good article with lots of pointers to get you started. I’m sure you can find someone in the birth family. I will pray for you guys. I look forward to your results and some closure to your moms questions. All the best to you in your search.


  3. Hi Kelly
    Loved your Part 1. I thought I would share the short version of my story, I was like the brother you found, but I was the one looking. I was raised as an only child and found out by accident I was adopted when I was around 8 years old, my parents had not planned on telling me. I started looking for who my biological parents were in 1999 after my parents died. To keep this short, I had very little to go on and I got lucky and found who they were, found who my birth mother was in 1999 and who my biological father was in 2018. I got to experience the wonderful side of finding my half siblings and the heart breaking side too.
    On the maternal side I found I had two sisters and a brother all older and we were all raised by different families, so we all had something in common and a natural curiosity. We all hit it off right away and met in 2000. We have remained close.
    Fast forward to 2018 I figured out who my biological father was and learned he had been married 5 times, but never to my birth mother. Turned out he fathered 11 children including me. I was the product of a time between two of his marriages. I found my youngest sister on the paternal side through a DNA site. I was a big surprise to her, she gave me quite a bit of information, but in the end it was to much for her to handle. I was the skeleton in the closet, the secret they wished had remained buried. I caused her to have to rethink what she thought knew of the past and what she knew about her father. She asked that I not contact her again. I have respected and can understand her wish. I left the door open for her if she ever wanted to contact me again. I learned three of my half siblings on the paternal side had already died. And it turned out none my biological father’s other 7 children wanted to know anything about me, which I have to say was disappointing and heartbreaking after searching for so long. I had prayed my entire life to find out who my biological parents were, it was a natural curiosity, a scratch I had to itch. God answered my prayers, but I believe he did it reluctantly as he knew the joy it would bring but also the heartbreak that would be included in the answer. I can see God’s hand in my finding who my biological parents were. My sister on the maternal side started looking for any siblings within two weeks of when I started searching in 1999. My youngest sister on the paternal side and I did Ancestry in 2018 within a few days of each other, by the way she is exactly 20 years younger than me. I don’t believe those were coincidences. Sorry this got longer than I had planned. I learned not all stories can have a happy ending and not all doors are meant to be opened.
    I look forward to your part two and I hope your story has a happy ending.


    1. Paul, thank you for sharing your story. Sorry, somehow I am just seeing the comment. I truly am amazed to hear how others have traveled the same journey. Life is a mystery that will be unveiled in God’s time and as He leads us to uncover it. I believe we are stronger in the end for it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s